To Filter or Not to Filter, That is the Question
CNet has an article on the effectiveness of web filters: Do Web filters protect your child? The answer is yes, to a certain extent, but they cannot be ultimately relied upon. Of course filtering in libraries is a touchy subject, because many of us are forced to filter by boards, other of us want to filter but can't, and then there are some of us who agree with the policy the board has created whether it is to filter or not.
In small libraries, the issue is that you either filter all computers or none. We don't have room to have a children's computer area and an adult computer area. Here in the library I run, we don't filter at all. Have we had issues? Yes. Have we dealt with them? Yes, and continue to. We have a tap-on-the-shoulder policy and have deliberately placed our computers in a very public area. So we simply ask people to stop. Our patrons, even those doing it, understand the problem and have almost always willingly stopped. There are exceptions (aren't there always?) but frankly we have more trouble with a man loudly swearing on his cell phone in the library than with porn on library computers.
We also have a policy where children under age 18 have to have parental permission (written) to acces the Net at the library. This has been very helpful on the rare occasions when we have a kid get into trouble online. We had one girl give out her name, personal information and PHONE NUMBER on a public chatroom. She got calls from men across the country. But her mother had signed the policy, and we had all warned her over and over not to do it. She was in the reckless teen mode and didn't care to listen. But she learned after that.
How about you? Do you filter? Does your policy work? Would you change it if you could?